14 Valentine’s Day Seafood Dinner Recipes

City Fish Market is excited to enhance romance with suggestions for seafood for two: 14 Valentine’s Day seafood dinner recipes. Anyone might find themselves in the mood for such dishes when browsing the fresh seafood products at our retail counters. Like many others, you could develop a yearning for our fresh seafood at 884 Silas Deane Hwy in Wethersfield. 

Share your passion by preparing any of the following dishes on the most romantic day of the year. The asterisked(*) recipes are found here, whether as a featured recipe or a recipe link: 15 Best Fish and Seafood Dinners for Two. Multiple versions of the other recipes are available via a simple online search.

1-Surf and Turf for Two*

Surf and Turf for Two brings together two indulgent favorites meant to be savored slowly. Juicy seared scallops or plump shrimp meet buttery filet mignon, a steak prized for its tenderness and quietly elegant presence on the plate.

2-Crab-Stuffed Lobster Tail*

This timeless seafood classic feels crafted for special moments. Sweet lobster tails are generously filled with seasoned crab meat and finished with warm lemon butter, adding richness and a celebratory touch to every bite.

3-Lobster Thermidor*

Lobster Thermidor is unapologetically indulgent. Tender lobster meat is folded into a creamy, cheese-kissed sauce with subtle mustard notes, then returned to the shell for a dish that feels both comforting and lavish.

4-Creamy Cod and Potato Gratin*

An elevated take on classic creamed cod, this dish layers flaky white fish with tender potatoes in a velvety sauce. Baked until golden and bubbling, it invites lingering at the table and quiet conversation between bites.

5-Pan-Seared Scallops with Lemon Cream

Sweet scallops are seared until beautifully golden, then finished with a silky lemon-garlic cream sauce. The gentle brightness paired with rich texture makes this dish feel intimate and effortlessly elegant.

6-Seared Ahi Tuna Steaks*

Ahi tuna steaks are lightly seared to highlight their natural flavor and refined simplicity. Clean, bold, and beautifully understated, they offer a restaurant-worthy experience without feeling heavy or fussy.

7-Mediterranean Stuffed Swordfish*

Thick swordfish steaks are filled with a savory blend of spinach and feta, bringing Mediterranean warmth to the table. Whether broiled or grilled, the result is hearty, fresh, and meant to be shared.

8-Chef John’s Shrimp Fra Diavolo

Shrimp Fra Diavolo delivers bold spice balanced by rich tomato flavor, creating a dish with just enough heat to keep things interesting. Generous portions make it perfect for sharing—and going back for seconds.

9-Creamy Tuscan Salmon

Tender salmon fillets rest in a luxurious sauce of cream, garlic, and sun-dried tomatoes. Comforting yet refined, this beloved dish feels like something you’d order on a memorable night out.

10-Creamy Lobster Fettuccine

This deeply indulgent pasta combines tender lobster with a rich, velvety cream sauce wrapped around fettuccine. It’s the kind of dish that slows the evening down and turns dinner into an experience.

11-Roasted Oysters with Lemon Garlic Butter

Roasted Oysters with Lemon Garlic Butter offer a classic blend of briny depth and rich aromatics. Served as a starter or light main, they set a sophisticated, quietly romantic tone for the meal.

12- Crab Legs with Garlic Butter Sauce*

Snow crab legs tossed in garlic butter create a relaxed, hands-on experience that invites sharing and conversation. Simple to prepare, they turn dinner into a moment rather than just a meal.

13-Grilled Tilapia with Mango Salsa

Grilled tilapia pairs effortlessly with fresh mango salsa, bringing brightness and balance to the plate. Sweet fruit and delicate fish come together in a way that feels light, fresh, and inviting.

14-Hazelnut Crusted Halibut with Garlic Mashed Potatoes*

This romantic pairing features halibut coated in a crisp hazelnut crust, paired with creamy garlic mashed potatoes. Elegant yet comforting, it’s a meal designed to be enjoyed slowly, together.

Shop City Fish for Valentine’s Day’s Main Ingredients

At City Fish Market, where the best-known aphrodisiac is always in plentiful supply, we hope you find these 14 Valentine’s Day seafood dinner recipes helpful. On any day of the year, whether you try these recipes, your own, or perhaps our seafood recipes, we have the freshest seafood to make the dishes shine!

Visit City Fish Market for the main ingredient in an unforgettable Valentine’s Day dish. For questions, you can call us or fill out our online form. In-store, our staff at the retail counters are also in the know and can help with any questions you may have. Best to stick to seafood enquiries, rather than, for instance, requesting advice on additional Valentine’s Day tips.